I’ve been listening to Modest Mouse’s We Were Dead Before The Ship Even Sank in preparation for writing this post. Then I spent a bit of time trying to figure out how to write something that was constructively critical, rather than saying “this album is the worst thing I’ve heard ever.” I guess that about sums things up, though. Isaac Brock sounds like the drunken sailor he’s always wanted to be, the backup vocals from James Mercer are shabby and completley uncalled for and I can honestly say I don’t like a single song on this entire album.
Honestly it sucks to have to write that. The early Modest Mouse albums are some of my favorite ever, but this new stuff is too different for me, it’s not the sound I enjoyed from them. Hopefully they’re happy making the music they make? The album went Gold, selling 500,000 records, so obviously I’m in a minority here. But that’s ok, to each their own.
For the wallpaper though, we have the fabulous Ellis Latham-Brown creating a super fun scene which is way better than the album itself. Ellis explains himself perfectly;
This was the first album produced by Modest Mouse since adding a new member, former Smiths guitarist Johnny Marr. I wanted to capture the spirit of this album as Issac Brock put it, a nautical balalaika carnival romp. I couldn’t think of a better grouping of words to describe it. I put the album on and went to work and this is what came out. The theme of being lost, or stranded comes up a lot in this album. I used that to form this scene of a captain who’s only companion is tragedy, portrayed by the beast. With all tragedy comes a silver lining. (The cake)